Home Home
Home | Overview | B-Schools | Jobs | Alerts | Advertise | Contact Us | About Us | Forum | Link to us
Tuesday, April 24, 2018 Choose Language: English | German | Portugese



MBA Resources
MBA Articles
MBA Books
MBA Case Studies
MBA B Schools
MBA Current Affairs
MBA Downloads
MBA Events
MBA Notifications
MBA FAQs
MBA Jobs
MBA Job Consultants
MBA News
MBA Results
MBA Courses
MBA Sample Papers
MBA Interview
Questions
MBA Training
Institutes
CAT - 2015 - 2016
Online CAT 15 - 2016
About Online CAT
How to Prepare for
CAT
CAT 2018 Faqs
GD Tips
Pursuing MBA
MBA aspirants
What is an MBA
Why an MBA
How to Prepare for MBA
Returning to B-school
Value of MBA
Good MBA Candidate
MBA Overview
Overview
MBA Accreditation
Scope of MBA
MBA Programs
Career in Vogue
B-School Ratings
Top Universities
Top 30 Ranking
Admission Process
Management Colleges
in Bangalore
Distance & Online
MBA Preparation
Aptitude Tests
Tips for CAT
GD Made Easy
MBA Entrance Exams
CAT's Eye
About CAT
CAT Class Room
CAT Course Materials
CAT Bulletin 2018
CAT Eligibility
CAT Test Centers
CAT Institutes
How to Apply
Important Dates
CAT Instructions
CAT FAQs
Sample Papers
CAT GD/PI
CAT Resources
CAT Results
MBA Careers
Business News
Case Studies
Interview Tips
Build Resume
Seminar Topics
Business Schools
B-Schools Profiles
B-Schools Rankings
B-Schools Selection
B-Schools Hot News
B-Schools Events
B-Schools Diary
B-Schools Seminars
Placements 2015
Placements 2014
Placements 2013
Placements 2012
Placements 2011
Placements 2010
Placements 2009
Placements 2008
Placements 2007
Placements 2006
Top Business Schools
Top Business Schools
(Part Time) in Asia
Top Business Schools
in India
Top Business Schools
Worldwide
Education Loans
Career Resource
Admission Process
Admission Alerts
MBA Admissions
Application Dates
Full Time
Part/Evening Time Programmes
Fellow Programmes
Executive MBA
Distance Courses
GMAT Preparation
What's GMAT
GMAT Books
Eligibility Fees
Importance
GMAT CAT
GMAT & MBA
GMAT FAQs
GMAT Preparations
GMAT Review
MAT Preparation
What's MAT
Exam Notification
Online MAT 2015 - 16
MAT Institutes
MAT Test Centres
AIMA Study Centres
Bank of Baroda
Branches
JMET Preparation
JMET 2018 Important
Dates
JMET 2018 Eligibility
JMET Application
Process
JMET Online Application
JMET Results and Score
JMET 2018
Participating Institutes
JMET Test Pattern
JMET Paper Structure
Analysis Zone
Analysis of MBA
Entrance Exams
Exam Notification
Mock Exams
Mock Exam [2018]
Verbal Preparation
Math (Quantitative)
Analytical
General Awareness
Free Downloads
Karnataka CET Papers
CAT Papers
XAT
FMS
MAT
IIFT
CET
SNAP
JMET
GMAT Verbal
GMAT Math
Miscellaneous
Distance Courses
Success Stories
Advertise With Us
MBA FAQs
MBA Forum



Home » Placements 2010 » About Placements » VGSOM, IIT Kgp placements 2010: 41 companies, IBM scoops 15, some still looking for jobs

VGSOM, IIT Kgp placements 2010: 41 companies, IBM scoops 15, some still looking for jobs


CLICK HERE : Expert Suggestions on Computer Based CAT : 2018 - 2019


VGSOM, IIT Kgp placements 2010: 41 companies, IBM scoops 15, some still looking for jobs

The Vinod Gupta School of Management (VGSOM), Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur released its placement report for the MBA batch of 2008-10 this week, claiming a total of 110 offers for an eligible-for-placements count of 80 students. With 15 job offers, IBM was the largest recruiter at the placements.

According to the institute, 45 companies participated in the process, though only 41 companies made final recruitments. A total of 11 students accepted pre-placement offers. Two students had opted out of the placements. “Both of them were Armed Forces guys. One is going back to army while one is retiring and would be starting something of his own,” said the institute. Not all students seem to have gotten jobs, even though the official placement season has ended.

VGSOM has claimed an overall average salary of Rs 11.37 lakhs per annum and that the statistical mode of the salary was Rs 9 lakhs, offered to 15 students. In the answers to a PaGaLGuY questionnaire, the institute also claimed that 62 candidates had offers equal to or above Rs 9 lakhs. The institute refused to clarify if these were just accepted offers or also included offers that were not accepted.

The highest salary was claimed as Rs 15 lakhs. All figures include variable salary components and other benefits over and above the in-hand component.

Profile breakup

Profile category

Percentage of offers

Some companies

Some profiles

Consulting

38%

AMI Partners, Avalon Consulting, Deloitte, Deloitte-USA, IBM, i-Maritime Infosys, KPMG, Wipro Consulting.

Strategy Consulting, Business Consulting, IT Consulting, SCM Consulting and Finance Consulting.

Operations

22%

ABB, Balmer Lawrie, BHEL, Heinz, ITC, Mahindra and Mahindra, Tata Motors, Vedanta Resources, UB Group, Welspun, BHEL, SCI

Supply Chain Management, Manufacturing Operations, Procurement. BHEL offered General Management

Finance

18%

ANZ, Bank of Baroda, Citibank, JP Morgan, Nomura, NCDEX, Power Finance Corporation, SBI Caps.

i-Banking, Banking Operations, Corporate Finance, Advisory and Structured Finance to Business Development in Commodities.

Marketing

11%

ABB, Berger Paints, Citrix, DataMonitor, ITC, Tata Metaliks, Tata Motors, Tata Telcon, Tech Mahindra

Sales & Distribution, Market Research, Product Marketing, other traditional marketing roles.

IT

5%

Not disclosed by the institute

Not disclosed by the institute

HR

5%

Not disclosed by the institute

Not disclosed by the institute

Apart from the above, students were offered jobs in analytics and statistics by ANZ, Dell, HP, and HSBC and Citigroup Global.

Analysis

On ’62 candidates having offers equal to or above Rs 9 lakhs’

While the institute’s placement committee gave us this data on email without our asking, it refused to answer our question if these were just accepted offers or also included offers that were not accepted, saying that “We would like to bring to your notice that all the relevant data is available in our Placement Report, which has been approved and authorized by the institute to be published.”

This implications of this difference are important, since “62 accepted offers >= Rs 9 lakhs” would mean that 62 distinct students out of a total batch of 80 secured more than or equal to Rs 9 lakhs. Whereas if they meant “62 of the total offers >= Rs 9 lakhs”, (total number of offers claimed is 110) then it means only 56.4% of the offers were above Rs 9 lakhs, some of them appearing as multiple offers shared among a small bunch of the brighter students. Yes, I can see that they have mentioned ‘candidates’, but after once writing it without our asking for it, they have refused to stand by it and provide data to corroborate their claim. A clarification about this would have been helpful, else it brings to mind the famous William Watt one-liner, “Do not put your faith in what statistics say until you have carefully considered what they do not say.”

The entire batch has not been placed yet

While VGSOM claims in its report that the official placement season has ended, it has not disclosed that there are students in the batch who are still looking for jobs because they did not find one in the institute-driven placements process. The following message posted on LinkedIn was passed to us by a source:

(We are not disclosing the student’s identity for obvious reasons.) This reporter spoke to the student on phone and he admitted to not having gotten a job at VGSOM until the closing of the placement process. “I did interview with a Kolkata-based company after the placement process, but they later turned back on their decision to send an offer letter citing lack of enough projects to make a new hire. So as of now I am still unplaced,” he added. The VGSOM placement committee refused to comment on the above and to our question “how many students had not been placed by the end of the placement season.”

Additionally, according to sources, two more students are without jobs until the end of the placements. Upon our calling them, they refused to either agree or deny if they had gotten a job during the placements, adding that VGSOM placements was a confidential system and they were not authorized to speak out-of-turn. (Disclosure: The information in this paragraph has been confirmed by one source, as opposed to multiple sources in other parts of the report.)

“B-schools are not placement agencies…”

One sees many b-school students and professors fall back on this argument when put into a corner on the subject of their b-schools’ respective placements.

At the same time, it is interesting how all b-schools behave like placement agencies – by revealing data selectively to portray themselves as having had good placements, not revealing how many students did not get placed, pushing out persuasive reports containing flowery language singing accolades about their exemplary placement scenario which reaffirms their status as one of the best, how recruiters make a beeline to that college despite unfavorable economic climates, how recruiters have reaffirmed their faiths in their b-school, etc etc. Compare this language and style of operation with the sales pitch put out by aggressive placement consultancies and spot the similarities.

But many times, students do not get placed because of their inability to communicate their strengths to recruiters, inadequate work experience, bad grades or just plain bad luck. None of this should be the b-school’s responsibility, as their jurisdiction at best ends with facilitation of conversations between students and recruiters. So if the argument by b-schools is that they are not placement agencies, they should logically have no hesitation in revealing how many people did not get placed at the end of the process.

This comment does not apply to VGSOM alone, but to all b-schools. This year since April, we have been trying to scratch below the surface of all placement reports, with the objective of providing balanced coverage, which perhaps no other media outlet has ever tried to do. As a result, we are often slightly late in publishing placement reports compared to our competitors. Our objective is anything but to malign b-schools, but to show our readers a balanced perspective of placement reports which by nature are biased and written with the explicit intention to persuade. While their right to persuade is valid, so is the media’s right to unearth all that vital information which was lost in the b-school’s endeavor to persuade. Else, wouldn’t we just be glorified PR agencies? But in our pursuit, we find that most b-schools start to feel uncomfortable with sharing data beyond a point and clearly ask us to keep off.

Discussion Center

Discuss

Query

Feedback/ Suggestion

Yahoo Groups

Sirfdosti Groups

Contact Us

 

 


Get MBA FAQS, JOBS, Questions & Answers

  • B-Schools Profiles
  • MBA Programs
  • MBA Walkins
  • Internet Marketing Interview Questions
  • Sales Interview Questions
  • Share Market Interview Questions
  • Strategic Marketing Interview Questions
  • Telemarketing Interview Questions
    Members Login Here!
    EmailId:   
    Password:


      Forgot Password?
      New User? Register!
    XAT 2019
    XAT Notification Date
    XAT Registration 2019 Procedure
    XAT Exam Pattern
    XAT Sample Papers
    XAT Previous Year Papers
    SNAP 2019
    SNAP Notification Date
    SNAP Registration 2019 Procedure
    SNAP Exam Pattern
    SNAP Previous Year Papers
    TISS 2019
    TISS Notification Date
    TISS Registration 2019 Procedure
    TISS Exam Pattern
    TISS PIT(GD)/PI
    Computer Based Test Practice link

    Interview Q & A eBook

    Get 9,000+ Interview Questions & Answers in an eBook. Interview Question & Answer Guide
    • 9,000+ Interview Questions
    • All Questions Answered
    • 5 FREE Bonuses
    • Free Upgrades

    Useful Resources

    Indian Institute of Management - Ahmedabad
    IIM - AHMEDABAD

    Indian Institute of Management -  Bangalore
    IIM - BANGALORE

    Indian Institute of Management - Calcutta
    IIM - CALCUTTA

    Indian Institute of Management - Indore
    IIM - INDORE

    Indian Institute of Management - Kozhikode
    IIM - KOZHIKODE

    Indian Institute of Management - Lucknow
    IIM - LUCKNOW


  • Master of Business Administration MBA course Exam Institution Admission Details Related Pages


    CAT | IIM | JET JMET | MBA | MBA Entrance | MBA Distance | MBA Entrance Exam | MBA Programs | Top MBA Universities in India | B-Schools Profiles | Management Colleges in Bangalore | Aptitude Tests | CAT Tips | CAT Bulletin 2008 | Common Admission Test | CAT Papers | XAT Papers | FMS Papers | MAT Papers | IIFT Papers | CET Papers | SNAP Papers | JMET Papers | GMAT Verbal Papers | GMAT Math Papers |

    Copyright © 2018. onestopmba.com. All rights reserved Privacy Policy | About Us | Terms and Conditions
    Our Portals : Academic Tutorials | Best eBooksworld | Beyond Stats | City Details | Interview Questions | Discussions World | Excellent Mobiles | Free Bangalore | Give Me The Code | Gog Logo | Indian Free Ads | Jobs Assist | New Interview Questions | One Stop FAQs | One Stop GATE | One Stop GATE | One Stop GRE | One Stop IAS | One Stop MBA | One Stop SAP | One Stop Testing | Webhosting in India | Dedicated Server in India | Free Website Templates | Sirf Dosti | Source Codes World | Tasty Food | Tech Archive | Testing Interview Questions | Tests World | The Galz | Lalu Yadav Jokes | Vyom | Vyom eBooks | Vyom International | Vyom Links | Vyoms | Vyom World | Shayari